Glycaemic index and glycaemic load
Archive ·
After a high glycemic load meal, blood glucose levels and insulin requirements rise more rapidly than after eating a low glycemic load meal.
Research has shown that food components that increase insulin resistance or insulin secretion, affect the risk of various diseases such as type 2 diabetes and coronary heart disease.
Although dietary carbohydrates appear to be directly related to this hypothesis, the nature of this relationship is complex. Higher carbohydrate consumption can increase insulin sensitivity, but some types of carbohydrates create insulin resistance and 'dangerous' lipid profiles. There are two main nutritional indicators used to express the glycemic effect of diet and carbohydrates respectively on the risk of certain diseases. These indicators are the glycemic index and the glycemic load.
Glycemic index
In the past, carbohydrates were categorized as simple or complex based on the number of simple sugars contained in their molecule. Carbohydrates made up of one or two simple sugars such as fructose or sucrose (table sugar) were called simple sugars, while starchy foods were called complex carbohydrates because starch is made up of long chains of the simple sugar glucose.
The advice to eat less simple and more complex carbohydrates was based on the assumption that the intake of starchy foods would lead to smaller increases in glucose levels than the intake of foods containing simple carbohydrates. This hypothesis appeared to be too simplistic since the 'glycaemic response' to complex carbohydrates showed considerable variation. A more accurate indicator of the relative glycemic response to dietary carbohydrates is the glycemic index.
Measuring the glycemic index of foods
The glycemic index qualitatively compares the ability of foods containing equal amounts of carbohydrates to raise blood sugar levels. In order to determine the glycemic index of a food, volunteers are given on different days the food in question which provides fifty grams of carbohydrates and a control food (white bread or pure glucose) which contains the same amount of carbohydrates. Blood samples are taken to determine the glucose levels, initially before the consumption of the food and then after the consumption of the food, at regular intervals during the following hours.
Changes in glucose levels over time are plotted as a graph. The glycemic index is calculated as the quotient of the areas of two surfaces: a) the area under the glucose curve of the tested food and b) the area under the glucose curve of the control food. The result of the division is multiplied by one hundred to represent the percentage of blood sugar elevation of the test food relative to the control food.
Thus, the baked potato has a glycemic index of 85 relative to glucose and 121 relative to white bread, which means that the glycemic response to carbohydrates of the baked potato is 85% of the glycemic response to the same amount of carbohydrates of pure glucose and 121% of the glycemic response to the same amount of carbohydrates of white bread. In contrast, cooked brown rice has a glycemic index of 55 relative to glucose and 79 relative to white bread.
Glycemic load
The various foods we consume do not contain equal amounts of carbohydrates, and in addition to the quality, it is the quantity of carbohydrates consumed that additionally affects the body's response to insulin secretion. The glycemic index says nothing about the amount of carbohydrates contained in a serving of food. For example, one may mistakenly assume that they should exclude carrots from the daily diet because they have a high glycemic index of 131 (compared to white bread).
The concept of glycemic load was developed by scientists to describe both the quality (glycemic index) and the quantity of carbohydrates of a meal or diet. In 1988 Jenkins began research on glycemic load and blood glucose control, while in 2002 Willet and his colleagues continued the research and concluded that replacing a high glycemic load diet with a low glycemic load diet resulted in a reduction in the risk of developing type 2 diabetes.
Glycaemic load and diabetes
After a high glycemic load meal, blood glucose levels and insulin requirements rise more rapidly than after eating a low glycemic load meal. High sugar levels and excessive insulin secretion are thought to contribute to the loss of insulin-secreting capacity of the pancreatic β-cells, which leads to irreversible diabetes. High glycemic load diets have been associated with an increased risk of developing diabetes in several large prospective studies.
Cardiovascular Diseases & Diabetes
Glucose intolerance and insulin resistance are known risk factors for cardiovascular disease as well as type 2 diabetes. In addition to causing higher blood sugar and insulin levels, high glycemic load diets were associated with 2 risk factors for coronary heart disease, namely increased serum triglyceride levels and decreased levels of 'good cholesterol' (HDL). They were also associated with increased levels of C-reactive protein (CRP), which is a sensitive 'sign' of cardiovascular disease risk.
Thus, if the concept of glycemic load is taken into account, recommendations to replace dietary fat with carbohydrates may not be as 'heart-healthy' as high carbohydrate consumption may result in increased concentrations of triglycerides and decreased concentrations of high-density lipoprotein [HDL] (protective against cardiovascular disease) in fasting plasma. Ultimately it seems that it is the quality of the carbohydrates that must replace the fat in our diet.
Glycemic index & Obesity
Most studies find that eating low-glycemic foods delays the return of hunger, reduces subsequent food re-intake, and increases feelings of satiety and fullness compared to eating high-glycemic foods.
The results of small and short trials (lasting 1-4 months) have shown that low glycemic load diets result in greater weight or fat loss than high glycemic load diets. It has also been shown that low glycemic load diets may prove helpful in long-term weight loss.
From everything mentioned above, it seems that everyone should now aim to reduce the glycemic load of their daily diet. So it remains to be clarified how this can be achieved. Some general guidelines could be the following:
- Increase consumption of fruits, vegetables, legumes (peas and beans), nuts and whole grains and generally foods that are rich in plant fiber.
- Reducing the consumption of starchy foods with a high glycemic load, such as sweet potatoes, spaghetti and white rice.
- Reducing the consumption of sugary foods such as cookies, cakes, candies and soft drinks.
Coeliac disease and gluten
In many cases it can help to prepare gluten-free food for the whole family, since it hardly differs in taste and certainly does not harm someone who does not have a problem with celiac disease.
A strict gluten-free diet is the only "treatment" for those suffering from celiac disease.
Of course, we need to be a little careful with hidden gluten because even the smallest amount can harm us - either by causing the known unpleasant symptoms, or not.
Some simple rules can ensure us the same eating habits and allow us to continue some special diet that we need to follow for other health reasons such as sugar, cholesterol etc.
Preparing gluten-free meals
- We cook with gluten-free raw materials, e.g. corn flour or special gluten-free flour instead of traditional wheat flour. We always cook gluten-free food separately and on a clean surface, thus avoiding mistakes and contamination from unsafe foods. In many cases it can serve to prepare gluten-free food for the whole family, since it hardly differs in taste and certainly does not harm someone who does not have a problem with celiac disease.
- We add to our diet as much as possible foods that do not contain gluten anyway, e.g. fresh vegetables and fruits, potatoes, rice, meat, fish, etc. We replace the rest with products from which gluten has been removed, e.g. pasta, bread, etc.
- When we eat out we prefer something grilled, e.g. meat, chicken, fish accompanied by grilled vegetables, rice and in general we avoid complicated cooked foods that may hide several risks. Special attention needs to be paid to the possibility of contamination from other foods with gluten, e.g. in the same grill to bake bread or pies.
- When shopping, we pay particular attention to the ingredients on the label and avoid those that mention gluten, but also those that contain unknown ingredients and additives, preservatives, colorings, etc. that may be dangerous. Let's not forget that many times the term gluten is not written exactly, but we can easily conclude from the context, e.g. wheat protein, wheat flour, cereals, etc.
- In addition to food, it is good to have our attention focused on other products with which we may come into contact, e.g. medicines, soap - shampoo - toothpaste, cosmetics, etc. It is good to inform our doctor and ask for alternative medicines without gluten and of course to prefer safe personal cleaning and care products.