MEDICAL LIBRARY

The Seven Countries Study and the Cretan diet

Archive ·

The Seven Countries Study started in the late 40s from the USA - its initiator and creator was the famous professor Ansel Keys, "Mr Cholesterol" as the Americans called him, as he was the first to express the connection "diet-heart", but also that between cholesterol and coronary heart disease.

Then he included other countries with different characteristics, different way of life. It is a classic landmark study, the longest of its kind, along with that of Framingham, USA. It initially covered 12,500 people between the ages of 40 and 60. The health of the volunteers was monitored, mainly regarding cardiovascular diseases, but also malignancies. At the time of the original report, research was continuing in our country by experts from the School of Medicine of the University of Crete, such as Professor Mr. A. Kafatos.

Greece was also included in the research following Professor Aravanis’ initiative. How was this initiative taken? The professor's own story gives the best answer: "When I left Greece for the USA, a young doctor, I had not yet seen a case of heart attack as a student but also as an intern. But after being in the US for graduate studies, I realized within a short period of time the tremendous difference in the incidence of heart disease. I said to myself that in Greece - and especially in rural Greece - there must be a different God in terms of health and another in the US, who does not protect citizens from heart disease."

Mr. Aravanis was informed by his colleagues in New York that a new epidemiological investigation examining the connection of diet with heart disease is being started in Minnesota by Ansel Keys. "Actually Keys in 1947 had started the research with a first group which consisted of railway workers. I met him in Washington in 1954 on the occasion of the second World Congress of Cardiology. He was a good-natured, very kind and intelligent man, with a sense of humor. I explained to him what was happening in Greece – although he himself was to some extent informed about the situation by Italian colleagues. We met again a year later at a conference of the American Medical Association in Chicago, where it was agreed that Greece should be included in the research, as it possessed special nutritional characteristics that create interest. Italy, the Netherlands, the former Yugoslavia – now Serbia –, Finland, Japan were also included in the investigation.

The selection of the sample in Greece was made with the following reasoning: the areas had to be far from the center, so that they would not have the influence of the life of the center - although Athens then had a face that by today's standards would make it a village. "Although the characteristics of the life and diet of the Greeks in the countryside were then roughly the same, we thought of reaching the farthest point, Crete. It was already known that in Crete the diet was a typical diet of a provincial people with a lot of oil consumption combined with hard agricultural work – physical exercise on a daily basis. The caloric consumption of the Cretans for their work was not great. It was characterized by quite a lot of fat – but when we talk about fat, we mean oil”.

A rural area 50 km outside of Heraklion, Kastelli Pediados, was finally chosen. The sample was of the order of 620 people in Crete and a year later when the research began in Corfu - in an area 45 km outside the city of Corfu - the same number of people were included. However, it was proven that even the population of Corfu did not show differences compared to the rest of the provincial populations in terms of diet or exercise. A total of 1,250 of these people have since had an annual follow-up in terms of recording any diseases and a five-year full review.

From this large research it emerged - mainly in what concerned the sample of Crete, since the Cretans were also the most consistent in their examination for so many years - that the lifestyle of the inhabitants of Crete is an important factor in longevity. Of the 620 people in Crete, 154 were still living the year before the original report was written. It appeared that of all the countries that participated in the research, the population of Crete had the lowest morbidity and mortality from cardiovascular diseases. The differences were so great that everyone spoke of the "Crete phenomenon". This phenomenon was attributed to diet and general lifestyle.

Study findings

The Seven Countries Study provided the scientific – and non-scientific – community with a famous term. That of the "Mediterranean diet". It is the most popular term used in nutrition through the endless list of more than 2,000 recipes and "recipes" that have been published. "And this happened because indeed the concept of the Mediterranean diet had an objective value.

This diet may have a lot of fat, but it is olive oil, which is known to have special characteristics: it does not increase cholesterol, it has antioxidant properties thanks to its vitamin E content. It also contains fruits and vegetables with a lot of fiber, a little red meat and dairy products in moderation. The consumption of wine is done in moderation in this diet." At the same time, the second "secret" of the longevity of the Mediterranean peoples, especially the Cretans, was hard exercise. “The calories these people consumed while working so hard were 2,500-2,800. That's why their subcutaneous fat index was very low compared to the other peoples examined."

However, a second first emerged from the research. Along with the term Mediterranean diet, the term risk factor was introduced for the first time. This term first appeared in 1961 simultaneously in two reputable American scientific publications: in "JAMA" ("Journal of the American Medical Association") and in "Circulation". In one form it was introduced through the Seven Countries Study as a pre-disposing factor for the disease and in the second through the Framingham study as a risk factor. The Framingham study is the second extensive longitudinal epidemiological investigation. It was conducted in the population of the Framingham, Massachusetts area, with the difference that women also participated in this survey compared to the Seven Countries Study.

As the Seven Countries Study showed, of the main risk factors for coronary heart disease – hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, obesity, smoking, inactivity, diabetes – the existence of just one is not so burdensome for health. "The combination or otherwise the "mafia of factors", even if each of them does not appear to a large extent, is the one that does the most damage. In fact, some combinations are more burdensome than others. For example, disorders of lipoproteins – cholesterol – together with smoking are a very bad combination for the heart. Worst of all, however, seems to be the triple cholesterol disorder – smoking – hypertension, says Mr. Aravanis.

The conclusions of this long-term research can be anything but optimistic. The world was freed from the great epidemics of the past such as plague or diphtheria, but experienced new great "epidemics" of non-communicable diseases. Cardiovascular diseases are today the number 1 killer in the modern world. These diseases, which were unknown in the Greece of the past, are today the greatest enemies of the health of the Greeks.

"Despite the progress that has been achieved in the field of research and treatment of diseases of the heart and blood vessels, the frequency of their occurrence at the global level and in our country is constantly increasing. Interventional cardiology may have offered many solutions – in many cases saved the lives of patients – but the big bet today for everyone is not to end up in the operating room. To eliminate heart problems, which are one of the greatest enemies of the health of the modern world" concludes Mr. Aravanis. These words, which belong to a man who has monitored heart disease in the Greek population for a long time - and not only - do not require further comment.

The study of seven countries showed us that the population of Crete was found to have the lowest mortality from coronary heart disease compared to all the rest. This is attributed to the frequent and extensive use of olive oil, oils, vegetables and fruits by the Cretans. Olive oil, in addition to reducing LDL-cholesterol (bad cholesterol) in the blood, prevents the oxidation of the fatty acids of HDL-cholesterol. This is done by the wide variety of antioxidant substances present in olive oil and olives such as tocopherols, polyphenols, squalene etc.

Olive oil is of great value for promoting health and preventing heart attacks and cancers. The author discusses the antioxidant content of 100 g of raw olive oil and its potential relevance to cell ageing and chronic disease.

Studies have shown that Cretan men are 3-5 times less likely to have a heart attack compared to men of the same age in northern European countries and the USA who have exactly the same total blood cholesterol levels. So, total blood cholesterol is not a good predictor of heart attack. That is why the oxidized form of LDL cholesterol has a much greater prognostic value for heart attack. The levels of oxidized LDL cholesterol in the blood are the lower the more antioxidants we get in our diet that are absorbed from the gut and enter the bloodstream.

Olive oil contains more than 600 substances called polyphenols. Most of these substances exert a strong antioxidant effect and protect the fatty acids of LDL-cholesterol from oxidation and thus have a lower atherogenic effect. Polyphenols protect the fatty acids of the cell membranes against oxidative damage, thus slowing down the aging of the body's cells.

Another important action of polyphenols is the binding of toxic free radicals that exist or are created in our body and which are believed to be responsible for initiating the cancer process. This is probably related to the fact that Cretans, in addition to having the lowest mortality from heart attacks, also had the lowest mortality from various forms of cancer.

Research over the last 40 years has shown that the traditional Greek diet is one of the healthiest on the planet. Perhaps this explains the paradox that despite all the bad habits we have as a people (low level of physical exercise and a lot of smoking) the figures cited at the time gave Greek men the longest life expectancy in Europe (75 years) while women also come fifth in the whole of Europe (80.3 years).
As it has been established, those who consume olive oil in their food have low "bad" cholesterol (LDL). This is because olive oil contains a wide variety of antioxidant substances (polyphenols, tocopherols, etc.), which intervene positively in favor of the body and reduce the amount of cholesterol, but also prevent its oxidation.

But what are the characteristics of the traditional Greek diet that make it so healthy? The scientists of the sector believe that it is the consumption of a wide variety of foods where fresh fruits, vegetables and wild greens play a dominant role, such as purslane (known in Greek as andrakla or glistrida), legumes, fish, olive oil, red wine and the small consumption of red meat and animal fats.

The basic principles that make up the characteristics of the traditional Greek diet are:

  • Plenty of plant-based foods such as fruits, vegetables, potatoes, grains and legumes
  • Olive oil as a base oil, replacing all other fats and oils. Reduce the consumption of trans fats that are abundant in pre-prepared sweets and foods and replace fats of animal origin (eg butter) with fats of vegetable origin (eg margarine). Soft vegetable margarines are low in saturated and free from trans fats, while at the same time they are rich in unsaturated fats. This makes margarines a much healthier choice than butter (including butter spreads and butter mixes), as butter is an animal product and high in saturated fat. It is no coincidence that international organizations, such as the American Heart Association (AHA) recommend the "use of margarine instead of animal butter" The same recommendation is made by the Australian Heart Foundation (Australian Heart Foundation) in addition, a large amount of research in the last decade shows that the daily intake of 2 g of plant sterols / stanols can reduce total and "bad" (LDL) cholesterol in percentages 6-15%. Because plant sterols and stanols are in low content in foods such as vegetable oils, fruits, vegetables, for this reason various foods have been enriched with plant sterols and stanols, such as margarines, dairy products (milk, yogurt).
  • Daily intake of small amounts of dairy products, such as cheese and yogurt.
  • Fish and poultry consumption on a weekly (not daily) basis. Foods containing omega-3 fatty acids such as fatty fish (salmon, tuna, trout and mackerel), nuts and green vegetables are preferred.
  • Eggs up to 4 per week (note that this number includes those used in cooking)
  • Consumption of sugar (which of course is present in sweets) on a weekly basis (not daily)
  • "Red" meat (beef, pork, etc.) only a few times a month
  • Physical activity (walking, movement in general) at the level that maintains the sense of daily health and well-being.
  • Reasonable wine consumption (usually 1-2 glasses of wine with meals)
Medical library